October is a great month for fun treats at McAlister’s Deli. Not only are they bringing back two fan favorite menu items, but there are also some new additions to the limited time menu as well.

Not only are we once again able to enjoy the iconic Witch’s Brew lemonade, but they have also brought back the Pumpkin Pecan Cookie with White Chocolate Chips! Both of these sweet treats are perfect for the season, and available throughout the month of October. And if you have never tried a Witch’s Brew Lemonade and you’re wondering what’s in it, then this is a classic lemonade that has a caramel apple syrup added in.

Of course, it’s not just returning favorites you’ll want to snag, as McAlister’s Deli is also giving us some new menu items to try in 2026. For this year’s menu we have:

– Franken-Tea – This is a combination of the Witch’s Brew Lemonade with the McAlister’s Famous Iced Tea!
– Twisted Witch’s Brew – This takes the OG lemonade to the next level with the addition of a black cherry puree.
– Peanut Butter Pie made with Reese’s – This one really needs no explanation (and our sweet tooth is already excited)!

With this menu, there is no reason not to head to McAlister’s Deli for a bit of spooky season magic. And if you happen to bring home a few extra treats, well who are we to judge!

What do you say fellow spooky season lovers? Are you excited for October at McAlister’s Deli? Which of these menu items are you trying first? Let us know in the comments below.